18F
18F - Comparative Analysis
Comparative Analysis systematically reviews existing products, services, or experiences that address similar user needs. This exercise analyzes user experience, information architecture, interaction patterns, and visual design. Teams examine direct competitors, adjacent solutions, and analogous experiences. They document strengths to emulate, weaknesses to avoid, and market opportunities. The analysis reveals industry conventions, differentiators, and potential best practices. Results inform design direction, feature prioritization, and positioning strategy.
Duration
3 hours
Group Size
3-6
Category
18F
Difficulty
Easy
Identify competitors' solutions that excel, are lacking, or are missing critical design elements. Comparative analysis provides a competitive edge. It helps identify opportunities, gaps in other services, and potential design patterns.
- Comparative analysis findings
- Clear understanding of the competitive landscape
- Identified opportunities and gaps
For an example, see the Draft U.S. Web Design Standards comparative analysis from USWDS GitHub. When working with government entities, remember to check for any Policy Review Act (PRA) implications.
Start the conversation
Be the first to share your thoughts, experiences, or questions!